Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Those cleared by DNA tests struggle to be free By Kevin Johnson, USA TODAY ST. LOUIS — Johnny Briscoe thought his nightmare was over in the summer of 2006 when, after 23 years of proclaiming his innocence, he finally walked out of a Missouri prison. DNA evidence lifted from a cigarette butt should have stripped away any doubt that another man — not Briscoe — had raped and robbed a woman in her suburban St. Louis apartment on Oct. 21, 1982. Yet Briscoe's exoneration, featured by national news organizations, did notfully free him from the persistent doubts of acquaintances and family members about his innocence, or from the emotional scars seared by more than two decades in prison. "Rape," says Briscoe, 54. "Now, that's a provocative word. When I try to explain it, it's a bitter pill." Nearly 90% of the 227 people cleared by DNA evidence since 1989 were convicted of some of the most heinous sex crimes, according to the Innocence Project, which helps inmates prove their innocence through DNA testing. DNA — present in blood, semen and body cells — can be particularly useful in solving sex crimes and often is the most definitive way of determining innocence. Yet not even DNA washes away the lasting stigma that shadows once-convicted sex offenders who are cleared by genetic testing, and the criminal justice system that wrongly jailed them offers little help. Briscoe's plight is part of a silent struggle for a rising number of exonerees. After high-profile releases from prison, they often fend for themselves. Most states did not account for the exonerated when officials started re-entry programs for the hundreds of thousands of offenders released in the U.S. each year. Most are ineligible for basic benefits, such as counseling and job training, that states give guilty offenders when they re-enter society. Despite legislative campaigns to get the wrongfully convicted financial help to compensate for the years lost in prison, 25 states still don't do so. In states that do, the money or services often are offered only if the exonerated waive their right to sue. Such lawsuits seek monetary damages for wrongful convictions and compensation for time in prison. The burden of re-integration into society is heavier for wrongly convicted sex offenders than for other exonerees, says Sim Platek, a New Jersey social worker who counsels exonerees, including those wrongfully convicted of sex crimes. "The shame of it goes deeper than any other shame," he says. "Very rarely do you see people fully recover from this immediately." Charles Chatman, 48, a Dallas-area man freed last year after 26 years in prison, tells of his "shame" in dealing with family members, many of them women, after his wrongful conviction — and even his exoneration — for aggravated rape. Other exonerees, such as Jerry Miller, 50, of suburban Chicago, carry court papers as commonly as driver's licenses to prove to potential employers and others that their convictions were overturned. Miller was convicted in the 1981 rape and kidnapping of a Chicago woman and spent 24 years in prison. He finished his sentence before being exonerated. In 2007, a year after his parole, he was cleared by DNA testing of the victim's clothes. Illinois officials required him to register as a sex offender and attend counseling after his release but before his exoneration. "My picture was on the Internet," he says of the required photo on the public sex offender registry. "I thought prison was bad. But (outside) I was like the scum of the earth." Illinois officials have since removed him from the state's database. James McCloskey, founder of Centurion Ministries, a Princeton, N.J.-based group that works to free the wrongfully convicted, describes the stigma as "a tremendous barrier." "When you hear the word 'rape,' " McCloskey says, "it scares the bejesus out of people." 'Seed of doubt' Rob Warden, executive director of the Center on Wrongful Convictions at Chicago's Northwestern University, says the indignities many exonerees suffer can be mind-boggling. "There are people out there totally exonerated, absolutely innocent who get notices that they need to register as sex offenders," Warden says. Platek says it is not unusual for some, after long periods in prison and protracted struggles to win exoneration, to exhibit symptoms similar to post-traumatic stress disorder. Others, he says, slip into depression, abuse drugs and alcohol or have paralyzing flashbacks to their time in prison. Among states that provide compensation, 10 also offer some tuition, health care or job-search counseling. The Innocence Project and its affiliates are pushing for uniform compensation laws and urging social service agencies to help exonerees. In Texas, for example, a group of defense lawyers got a local clothing store to give shirts, pants and jackets to exonerees who leave prison with no street clothes. Most were wrongfully convicted of sex crimes, and many scramble after their release to find shelter, health care and jobs. Even when they find work, stability can be elusive. One 58-year-old Centurion Ministries client, cleared of rape in 2006, was hired by a New Jersey food store about two years ago, McCloskey says. A prison guard who visited the store recognized the former inmate, and word spread among other workers that the business had hired a sex offender. As a result, McCloskey says, the former inmate was transferred to another store 70 miles away, then fired. Rather than sue the employer and call more attention to himself, he looked for a new job. "There is always that stigma, that seed of doubt that follows these guys," McCloskey says. Miller says he "dreaded" Halloween 2006 after his release from prison because, as a registered sex offender, he could not interact with children. On Halloween, he says, he felt humiliated when three police officers arrived to ensure he was complying. "I was told that if I answered the door, I would be arrested," Miller says. "So, I cut off the lights and sat there by myself. That was pretty tough." 'He was still incarcerated' When Johnny Briscoe came home July 19, 2006, time had rearranged the streetscape of his hometown St. Louis and dramatically altered his family. Close relatives, including his father, had died while he was in prison. His son, Donyea — 2 when Briscoe was convicted — was 25. "I couldn't believe it," says Briscoe, a carpenter and handyman. For months after his release, Briscoe spent most of his time in the tiny, upstairs bedroom of his mother's house. He arranged the room much like his prison cell — everything within arm's reach. "He was acting like he was still incarcerated," says his sister, Ruth Briscoe. "I think he was more scared being out than being in (prison)." Briscoe, a soft-spoken man with an easy smile, felt secure enough to leave home only with a "witness." He believed he needed a companion, usually Ruth, to vouch for his whereabouts and to help him avoid encounters — no matter how innocent — that could leave him vulnerable to accusations. When he did go out, he didn't go far. And he was always back by 10 p.m. "I didn't want to fall into any traps," he says of the sexual assault charges levied against him more than two decades earlier. In that case, a victim whom he had never met, in a part of town he had never visited, picked him out of a police lineup. Mistaken identity by witnesses and victims is one of the most common factors in wrongful convictions, the Innocence Project says. He was included in the lineup after another man who later was implicated in the crime — an acquaintance of Briscoe's — identified himself to the victim as "John Briscoe." The false identification started a chain of events that ended in Briscoe's 1983 conviction and 45-year prison sentence. For about five months, he was in a cell next to the acquaintance, Larry Smith. After suspecting Smith's possible connection, Briscoe confronted Smith outside their cells one day. "He denied it," Briscoe says. Smith is serving a life sentence for a separate sexual assault at the same apartment complex involved in Briscoe's case. Smith was identified in 2006 in the same DNA tests that excluded Briscoe. Although the DNA evidence points to Smith, J.D. Evans, St. Louis County's first assistant prosecutor, says the testing was not conclusive enough to support formal charges against Smith. "For a year and a half (after being released), I was really paranoid," Briscoe says. His ex-wife, Lynette Briscoe, 54, and Donyea also felt uneasy. Lynette, who divorced Briscoe 10 years into his prison term, says she was "angry" he was convicted and she was left alone. Even she was not convinced of her former husband's innocence. Neither was Donyea. Ruth says her nephew came to her after Briscoe's release. "He didn't know how to talk to (his father)," she says. "He was more comfortable asking me, 'Do you think he did that?' " Since then, Johnny Briscoe says he and his son rekindled a relationship denied 23 years ago. Lynette Briscoe, who never remarried, is seeing her former husband again. "Our life was taken away from us," she says, and a "chapter was never closed." Other family members remain distant. "They believe that he's still a convict," Ruth Briscoe says. "I just leave it be," her brother adds. " I can't change it." No simple answers Briscoe's attorney, Burton Newman, says his client is trying to regain a sense of normalcy. Briscoe is suing St. Louis County and four county police officers for his wrongful conviction rather than accept state compensation of $36,000 for every year spent in prison. It could take months to resolve the lawsuit, but he's now comfortable enough to go shopping and run errands alone. Yet his search for full-time work has been a bust. Applications for about a dozen positions have gone unanswered. The sour economy is a factor, but Briscoe suspects many prospective employers are turned off by his background. On each employment application, he says he has acknowledged the conviction and the circumstances of his exoneration. To improve Briscoe's chances of getting work, Newman recently advised him not to admit to the conviction, arguing that it has been wiped away by exoneration. Exonerations clear criminal records, but it often takes time to update the system. Some wait months for pardons. For Briscoe, there is no simple way to deal with questions about his past. "It is my job to convince everyone I didn't do this," he says. Jessie Burnley, Briscoe's 80-year-old mother, has no trouble defending her son. She carries a news clipping of his release — frame and all — to show anybody who asks. "I take it to church, everywhere, to tell (people) that my son is innocent," she says.

13 comments:

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now keep it up!

Anonymous said...

The reason for this is muscle is build up when your physical exercise burns your
fat. HIV and Single's mission, as stated on their website is to help people living with HIV find friendship, love and companionship without the fear of disclosure, stigmas or judgment. Die Acai Beeren kommen ursprünglich aus dem Regenwald des Amazonas und dort stellen diese Früchte seit Jahrzehnten eine signifikante Zutat des Essens der Indianer dar.

my blog ... 5 kilo Abnehmen

Anonymous said...

I was wondering if you ever thought of changing the page layout of
your blog? Its very well written; I love what youve got to say.
But maybe you could a little more in the way of content so people
could connect with it better. Youve got an awful lot of text for only having
1 or two pictures. Maybe you could space it out better?



Visit my weblog: simply click the following webpage

Anonymous said...

It can, however, be pre-ordered, as its release date is in the
near future. replica cartier earrings. I thought it would be
cool to make people laugh as I inquire into the things that
fascinate me, like the trap of being human and, at
the same time, divine. you ask with softness coming back into your voice
as you sit on the sand beside me. Their history timeline details how the greenhouse covered 4,000
square feet, and in 1976, a 6,000 square foot greenhouse was added.
"What have you Googled lately. Today, the scenario is entirely different. In fact the publicly owned Ecopetrol has seen an immense FDI surge in the past few years and in spite of being overvalued to some, the stock still is a good bet due to the growth potential it has. Vision for Space Exploration Cover by NASA used under Public Domain. Therefore, you cannot afford to miss this incredible shooter game involving a series of killings.

my homepage ... thefootballinme.com

Anonymous said...

This site was... how do you say it? Relevant!
! Finally I've found something that helped me. Thanks a lot!

my web page kostenlos spiele spielen

Anonymous said...

Сonsideг running a contest or offering a free product tiр sheet that accompanies
the іntеrѵіew. Yet
anothеr way tο conѕtruct a devicе tο haгnesѕ energy from radіο ωaveѕ is usіng an antеnna,
connеcted to a seгiеs оf dioԁes and a
capacitor bаnk thаt іs еaгthed.

It іs a morе reliable choіce when compared to tгadіtional conсrete or wοoden barrieгs for severаl reasons.


my webѕite :: myvideo downloader

Anonymous said...

I haгdly сomment, hoωever i did a feω sеarching аnd wounԁ up heгe Untіtled.
And I do have а сouρle of quеѕtions
fοr you if you usuallу do not mind. Iѕ it simply me or does it appear like a fеw
of these comments loоk as іf they are coming from brain dеad folκs?
:-P And, if yоu are pοsting on aԁdіtіonаl places, I'd like to keep up with everything new you have to post. Could you make a list of the complete urls of all your communal pages like your Facebook page, twitter feed, or linkedin profile?

Here is my weblog ... myvideo downloader
My site: click through the up coming post

Anonymous said...

Great blog here! Also your site loads up very fast!

What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to
your host? I wish my web site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

Also visit my site - video downloader

Anonymous said...

Hey there exceptional blog! Does running a blog such as this
take a great deal of work? I have very little knowledge of coding however I was hoping
to start my own blog in the near future. Anyhow, should you have any suggestions or
techniques for new blog owners please share.
I understand this is off subject but I just needed to
ask. Cheers!

Also visit my webpage: internetradio

Anonymous said...

The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has made available to communities
literature which provides guidance and technical information educating
communities on how to become disaster resistant in the face of natural disasters.
Their producers imagine this can make the user a lot more mindful in the should
change the batteries, lessening the prospect of the discover program failing through ability
loss. Double Tap (Tap the home button twice > Press
down on an app for one second > Hit the "minus" button on all apps that
are running) When you open an app, it stays running until you
actually turn it off.

Also visit my web page: gratis spiele spielen

Anonymous said...

When you quit, you can immediately feel its decision within 24 hours, health benefits, which
can cause you to not smoke forever. An alternate electrical power source reduces the probability that the access technique
will turn out to be inoperable via strength reduction and aid conserve battery lifestyle.
Mobile computing is continuously getting better with best performance, smarter processors, light weight and handy
designs, but as we all know, the main power of the
mobile computing device (weather it is laptop, mobile, PDA
or e-book reader) resides in it's battery capacity.

Feel free to surf to my web-site - Click On this website

Anonymous said...

Thіs infогmation is woгth eνeryonе's attention. How can I find out more?

My page ... raspberry ketone uk

Anonymous said...

Pесuliar article, totally what I wаnted to
finԁ.

my ѕite - vistaprint coupon code